My God, what have I done? All across the country, investors in all sectors and companies must be asking themselves the same thing. I know my friends are. After yesterday’s huge [emotional] rally in all sectors but one (energy), today seemed completely irrational. Everything fell. This was more than profit-taking. All of yesterday’s gains, 280 points, were shaved off the Dow as the index slipped all day to close down to $11,230, as investors in the financials asked themselves one extra question: “will any financial survive?”
Lehman Brothers (LEH), Washington Mutual (WM), Radian Group (RDN), PMI Group (PMI), Ambac Financial (ABK), First Marblehead (FMH), MBIA, Inc. (MBI), MGIC Investment (MTG), Triad Guarantee (TGIC), and Thornburg Mortgage (TMA) are just some of the financial institutions that had double-digit percentage losses today, and those are just the ones with losses greater than 10%. Citigroup (C), Bank of America (BAC), JP Morgan (JPM), SunTrust (STI), American Express (AXP), and even Visa (V) and MasterCard (MA) lost today. Lehman Brothers (LEH) is reporting their third quarter earnings tomorrow- a week early- after their Korea Development Bank deal fell through and its stock price lost 45% of its value today. LEH stock did bump up 7% in afterhours trading, so maybe there’s good news on the horizon. But no doubt, this bad news cast even more doubt into the financial sector today and helped push share values down. Today was very, very painful. Luckily I was so busy at work, with teaching, duties, and meetings, that I had no time to sit down and digest what was happening.
But my friends did. One of my stock friends, who has made a small fortune day-trading these financials, sent me an article that eased my mind a bit. It definitely crossed my mind a few times in the last couple days that my experiment may not work out after all, but the article he sent gave me some hope. It was titled “S&P Picks and Pans: Wells Fargo, Washington Mutual, TW Telecom, JC Penney, Avery Denison”, and was an article in BusinessWeek online. After all the upgrades and downgrades and rating cuts by people with questionable credentials and too much power, it was nice to read an article from a reputable source deeming one of my stocks, WM, a “hold”. If Washington Mutual is a hold and its going through some actual concrete, documented troubles, then my thinking (and hope) is that yesterday and today’s major sell-offs were out of pure fear. But I still hope the sell-off doesn’t continue!
A Reuters article from yesterday titled “Ambac’s planned muni insurer may be hit by changes” shed some light on what the common sentiment towards the mortgage and bond insurers might be. “In another even more fundamental change, agencies are mulling a shift in how they rate muni debt, using the same scale used for corporate debt. That would result in widespread rating upgrades for municipal bonds, which have a much smaller risk of default than corporate bonds. Higher ratings would in turn reduce the need for insurance.” If there’s less risk of default, then there’s less need for insurance.
One last article I’ll quote, this one from MarketWatch.com titled “Community building ire MarketWatch readers kindle own outrage over Fannie, Freddie takeover” quoted ArthurDental, who is a member of the MarketWatch Community. “”Everyone gets upset about financial aid to the poor,” ArthurDental wrote, “but where’s the outrage when taxpayers foot the bill because some ‘investments’ went sour? So stockholders would be largely wiped out; why then aren’t bondholders made to pay for their mistakes, too?”
It’s telling that this article didn’t hit yesterday when the market soared, but ArthurDental is right. When SSBX failed, I lost my investment. But when Freddie and Fannie exposed themselves to trillions of dollars in bad mortgages and therefore didn’t have the capital to pay the bonds it issued to China, the two lending giants got a slap on the wrist and trillions of our taxpayer dollars. Hey, I made a mistake investing in a company run by a McCain, where’s my money? It ain’t coming and I have to deal. And that’s the way it should be.
That Hurricane Ike took a turn south, and the Organization of the Petroleum Exporting Countries (OPEC) will likely maintain its oil production even though demand is down, caused the price of crude oil to fall to a 5-month low. Crude oil lost $3.08 to close the day at $103.26 a barrel. I lost $1700 today, or in my brother’s terminology, “seventeen hundo”. Ouch.
So what is going to happen now that the rules of the game have completely changed? I don’t dare speculate. But whatever it is that eventually happens seems as if it won’t make itself known for a while. For now, I’ll keep the faith. I took a gamble and put in a limit order for 25 more shares of WM today, and you can imagine my surprise when I signed on later, saw the stock price was at $3.30, and that my order executed at $3.60. When I put the order in, I assumed it was so low that it would expire unexecuted.
And more than anything, tomorrow’s a new day when anything can happen.